Political Digital Advertising: Key Insights from The Ad Wars Panel at Next Campaign Summit 2026
Political digital advertising has become the backbone of modern political and advocacy campaigns; but as spending increases and tools evolve, the real question in 2026 isn’t where to advertise. It’s how. That tension, between innovation and fundamentals, was at the heart of “The Ad Wars: Digital Advertising in 2026,” a featured panel at the Next Campaign Summit 2026, moderated by Harneet Singh, Managing Principal at EOK Consults and one of the founders of the event. Harneet Singh is a veteran of 100+ political and advocacy campaigns across Canada and has advised senior Cabinet ministers, Members of Parliament, provincial representatives, municipal leaders, and national advocacy organizations. The panel brought together three of Canada’s most experienced political and advocacy advertisers: Megan Buttle, President, Data, Digital & Design at Earnscliffe Strategies Nat Wilson, CEO of Point Blank and strategist for labour and progressive campaigns Dennis Matthews, President of Creative Currency and former advertising manager for Prime Minister Stephen Harper Together, they offered a candid look at what is shaping political digital advertising in 2026, and what campaigns need to rethink fast. From Megaphone to Strategy: The Real Shift in Political Digital Advertising A recurring theme across the discussion was that the biggest change in recent election cycles hasn’t been platforms or tools: it’s mindset. As Singh noted during the panel, campaigns increasingly succeed or fail based on whether digital is treated as a core strategic function, or merely a distribution channel for content created elsewhere. Megan Buttle echoed this shift, highlighting how serious campaigns are now integrating research, data, creative, and media buying into a single, coherent digital strategy. Digital is no longer a subset of communications. It’s a discipline in its own right, one that demands speed, testing, and alignment across paid, owned, and earned channels. Platform Strategy in 2026: One Size Does Not Fit All One of the most practical insights came from Dennis Matthews, who emphasized that campaigns still underestimate how differently content performs across platforms. A common mistake, he noted, is assuming that once an ad has been produced and paid for, it should be used everywhere. In reality: A landscape video built for YouTube rarely performs the same way on Instagram TikTok requires pacing, tone, and authenticity that Meta does not Connected TV (CTV) rewards clarity and emotional resonance, not rapid-fire messaging Effective political digital advertising in 2026 requires platform-specific creative, not just resized assets. Each channel has its own audience expectations, formats, and behavioural cues; campaigns that ignore those differences waste both attention and budget. Authenticity Still Wins, Especially for Advocacy and Labour Campaigns Nat Wilson brought the conversation back to a principle that consistently proves true in both electoral and advocacy work: authenticity matters more than polish. In her experience running high-impact labour, progressive, and issue-based campaigns, the most effective digital ads are often the ones that are unapologetically clear about who they are and what they stand for. Rather than smoothing out edges or trying to appeal to everyone, successful campaigns: Lead with values Speak in a human voice Embrace their identity and audience In a crowded digital environment, clarity cuts through. Authenticity isn’t just a tone choice, it’s a strategic advantage. AI in Political Digital Advertising: Accelerate Strategy, Don’t Replace Judgment Artificial intelligence was a major focus of the discussion, but the panelists offered a notably grounded perspective. Megan Buttle highlighted AI’s growing role in ad variation, testing, and speed, particularly when paired with strong research and audience insights. Nat Wilson added an important distinction: while her team uses AI for efficiency and workflow, they intentionally do not rely on AI for creative assets. Emotion, judgment, and cultural understanding, she argued, still require human leadership — especially in political and advocacy advertising, where trust and tone are fragile. Dennis Matthews reinforced this caution, noting that while AI can enhance execution, campaigns must remain vigilant about message flattening and unintended risk. The consensus was clear: AI works best when it accelerates good strategy, not when it replaces it. First-Party Data and the Trust Equation in Political Digital Advertising Across the panel, there was strong agreement that first-party data is now one of the most valuable assets a campaign can own. Email lists, SMS subscribers, website traffic, and engaged social followers allow campaigns to: Segment audiences more precisely Deliver relevant, timely messaging Reduce reliance on broad, inefficient ad buys But with that power comes responsibility. Trust, as multiple panellists emphasized, is fragile. Consistency of narrative, frequency of presence, and alignment across paid, earned, and owned channels matter more than ever. Campaigns must assume that everything is public, searchable, and shareable, and be prepared to respond and correct misinformation quickly. Storytelling in 2026: Human Still Beats Perfect When the conversation turned to storytelling, the panel agreed on a key point: the best-performing digital ads are often not the most technically sophisticated. As Singh noted from EOK’s experience running campaigns across multiple provinces, some of the strongest results came from: Real voices Imperfect footage Clear stakes and values Megan Buttle reinforced that research-informed storytelling, grounded in audience insight, remains essential, regardless of platform or format. Technology may evolve, but persuasion is still human. Final Takeaways for Political Digital Advertising in 2026 As Canada heads into a busy cycle with municipal elections across multiple provinces and the possibility of future federal contests, the panel’s insights point to a clear set of priorities: Treat digital as strategy, not just amplification Build platform-specific creative, not generic content Use AI to enhance speed and testing, rather than replace human judgment Invest early in first-party data and trust Lead with authenticity and clarity Political digital advertising in 2026 is more complex, more powerful, and more consequential than ever. Campaigns that get digital advertising right will shape the conversation. Those who don’t will struggle to be heard. “The Ad Wars: Digital Advertising in 2026” was presented at the Next Campaign Summit 2026, bringing together campaign professionals, advocates, non-profits, and public-sector leaders from across Canada to examine what’s next in campaigning and advocacy.